The Property Brief — what the evidence shows. You draw the conclusion.
Confidence: Low — based on 69 comparable auction sales (0 of this exact configuration) · model runs ±19% for this configuration · confidence held at Low — under 20 same-configuration sales · thin comparable support for this configuration — read the range as wider, not as a warning · the model's typical miss is ~11% against published results — every hit and miss
Comparable auction sales
| Address | Config | Sold | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5/411-413 Mona Vale Rd | 2 bd · 2 ba | $1.06M | Sept 2025 |
| 20/1-5 Lynbara Av | 2 bd · 2 ba | $1.11M | Sept 2025 |
| 523/17-19 Memorial Av | 2 bd · 2 ba | $1.1M | June 2025 |
| 101/12 Shinfield Av | 2 bd · 2 ba | $1.15M | June 2025 |
| 51/212-216 Mona Vale Rd | 2 bd · 2 ba | $878k | Mar 2025 |
Suburb risk flags
crime index: 15 — below sydney average · trains ~every 4 min at peak
Where every number comes from
- Fair value: AI PropertyEye price model 2026-08-11-v5 — trained on 146,492 published auction sales; configuration-level (suburb × type × beds), not an appraisal of this exact home
- Comps: published Domain auction results for St Ives — suburb × configuration matches, not hyper-matched to this address
- Risk flags: suburb-level overlays (BOCSAR crime, flood/bushfire intel, aircraft bands, GTFS transit) — NOT a per-parcel assessment
Rent evidence — asking vs transacted, St Ives · postcode 2075
$850–$900/wk is what 2-bed units in 2075 actually transact for (middle half of 37 bonds lodged, Q2 2026 · median $880/wk — NSW Fair Trading, CC BY).
2019Q1 → 2026Q2: $610 → $880/wk · +6% over the last 12 months (latest four quarters averaged against the previous four) — quarterly new-tenancy medians for units in 2075, all bedroom counts pooled.
Asking rents are what agents hope for; bond figures are what tenants actually signed at (NSW Fair Trading bond lodgements, CC BY). No yield % is derived here: each rent above is a different grain from this home's price, and a ratio of two grains reads as precision it doesn't have. New-tenancy rents run hotter than sitting rents. Not financial advice.
Growth trend — St Ives units at auction
Too few same-bed sales for a measured growth rate yet. Recent quarterly sold medians (all unit sizes — thin samples move these):
2024Q3 $905k (9) · 2024Q4 $1436k (8) · 2025Q1 $1073k (4) · 2025Q2 $1125k (4)
Suburb-level, from published auction results. No single building has enough sales for a block-level series, so this is the honest grain; sales-mix shifts move raw medians, and the measured rate (when shown) controls for bed count.
Published auction results at this address
| Auction week | Result | Price | Agency |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Aug 2026 | Sold | withheld | Ray White Upper North Shore |
| 18 July 2026 | Postponed | withheld | Ray White Upper North Shore |
From Domain's published weekly auction results — individual outcomes as published; withheld prices stay withheld.
Agencies' own published sales nearby — St Ives, around 2 beds
| Address | Sold | Price | Beds | Agency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 266/132-138 Killeaton Street | by 17 Aug 2026 | $805,000 | 2 | Meriton |
| 234/132-138 Killeaton Street | by 17 Aug 2026 | $880,000 | 2 | Meriton |
| 313/17-19 Memorial Ave | by 17 Aug 2026 | $1,018,000 | 2 | Meriton |
Prices as published on the selling agency's own website (their sold pages) — includes private-treaty sales the auction results never see. Only sales the agency chose to publish a figure for appear here.
Planning & zoning — R2 Low Density Residential
Houses and dual occupancies. A protected low-rise street — little chance of towers next door.
Zone R2 (Low Density Residential) under the KU-RING-GAI LEP, from the NSW ePlanning layers at this address's geocoded point — a guide, not a parcel-level legal check. Confirm the exact lot at the NSW Planning Portal.
Construction risk — what no listing tells you
Building Commission NSW / Strata Community Association 2023 Strata Defects Survey: 53% of newly registered strata buildings reported at least one serious defect in common property (39% in the 2021 survey). Defects are common, not exceptional — and new does not mean safe (Opal Tower was under a year old).
Get an independent structural and strata inspection before you commit — the defect base rate makes it the single highest-value dollar in the purchase.
We cannot see inside a building — no one can from public records. This section states base rates and observable adjacency only, and will never call a building safe.
The building — its registered strata scheme
Strata plan SP87639 registered 2012 — the building is at least 14 years old · 300 lots in the scheme (large scheme — expect facilities and higher levies).
Registration is an age floor, not a build date — a converted building is older than its strata plan. Scheme records from the NSW Strata Hub. © State of New South Wales (Spatial Services, a business unit of the Department of Customer Service NSW). For current information go to spatial.nsw.gov.au.
School catchments
St Ives NPS (primary) · St Ives HS (secondary)
3 primary schools within 2 km · ICSEA ~1131 — the socio-educational advantage of the school community (My School, national average ~1000): a demographic measure, never a results or quality score.
NSW DoE intake zones at this address's geocoded point — tighter than a suburb-level guess, but geocodes carry a few metres of error and boundaries change with reviews. Verify the exact address at School Finder. Intake zones cover government schools only.
Want the numbers agents don't volunteer?
Check any Sydney suburb free — Market Mint market-conditions readout, live median, clearance trend and the price model — at aipropertyeye.com. No sign-up for the suburb check; the full board is 7 days free.
Data from published auction results (Domain) and live portal listings. Estimates are never valuations or financial advice. Own this home and want a result corrected? hello@aipropertyeye.com.